Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive: Navigating Trough the Turmoil

We are currently living in times where, next to rapid technological advancements, environmental and social requirements enter into every pore of society. This refers to businesses as well, where new methods of conduct are adopted, trying to reduce their carbon footprint on the environment, while simultaneously being inclusive of individuals with various social backgrounds and thinking.

The European Union (EU) is no short of attempts in that regard so it introduced the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or CS3D) – a proposed legislative framework by the European Commission.

 

Purpose

The CSDDD is a part of a wider EU agenda - to encourage companies to integrate Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) factors into their decision-making processes, ensuring that their activities do not have negative impacts on society or the environment. It aims to foster sustainable and responsible corporate behavior, requiring companies to demonstrate actions they are undertaking to protect the environment and human rights, thus contributing to EU’s and the world’s effort to mitigate climate change and achieve the goals of the Paris Agreement.

Because of its goal, the CSDDD is expected to increase trust in businesses, improve risk management and contribute to a healthier environment and increased, higher-quality protection of human rights.

 

Scope

The CSDDD applies to both EU and, to an extent, non-EU companies because the non-EU companies will have to apply measures from the Directive if they plan to operate in the EU area. Furthermore, whether operating or not in the EU, the non-EU companies will certainly feel a “peer pressure“ from their EU counterparts to adopt similar measures in their business.

To be more precise in terms of scope, not only does the CSDDD cover EU and non-EU companies (including those in the financial sector, among others as per some sources), but it largely covers companies with more than 500 employees and a net worldwide turnover of more than EUR 150 mil. Those are the so called Group 1 companies. The Group 2 ones are the companies with 250+ employees and net worldwide turnover of more than EUR 40 mil, operating in defined high impact sectors - textiles, agriculture, extraction of minerals, provided that at least 50% of the turnover is made within those sectors. There are also Group 3 and 4 (non-EU) companies – the non-EU companies that generated a net turnover of more than EUR 150 mil. in the EU in the last financial year (Group 3) and the ones that generate more than EUR 40 mil. net turnover in the EU, provided at least 50% of worldwide turnover was generated in a high-impact sector (Group 4).

 

Key Features

In general, as its name suggests, the Directive imposes a due diligence duty on companies to identify, prevent, mitigate, and account for negative human rights and environmental impacts in their operations, subsidiaries and value chains. Hence the pressure part on non-EU companies mentioned above, because the EU companies would have to reevaluate their business from top to bottom, encompassing their collaborative non-EU companies in the value chain, expecting such companies to demonstrate their due diligence initiatives and practices in order to maintain strong business ties. The material scope of the CSDDD encompasses the entire value chain, upstream and downstream (direct and indirect business relationships), where upstream value chain includes all company’s activities related to product manufacturing, and downstream value chain includes all activities conducted by business partners regarding distribution, transportation, storage and disposal.

Bearing in mind the above, the key features of the Directive are the steps that companies need to undertake in order to implement the purpose of the Directive, i.e. to perform the due diligence in the following manner (Articles 5-11 of the CSDDD):

• Integration of due diligence into companies’ policies and risk management systems – the companies would be required to implement a due diligence policy outlining their approach to due diligence, as well as code of conduct that all the employees and subsidiaries must adhere to, while providing a description of the processes put in place to implement due diligence, including the measures taken to verify compliance with the code of conduct and to extend its application to established business relationships. This policy should be updated annually (Article 5 of the Directive);

• Identification – by way of Article 6 of the proposed Directive, the companies would need to take appropriate measures to identify actual and potential adverse human rights and environmental impacts arising from their own operations or those of their subsidiaries and, where related to their value chains, from their established business relationships (direct and indirect);

• Prevention and mitigation of potential adverse impacts, and bringing actual adverse impacts to an end and minimizing their extent – this step is pretty much self-explanatory so to concretize it the actual examples of this point are by developing action prevention plan, seeking contractual assurances from business partners with whom the company has a direct business relationship, make necessary investments in business infrastructure, support SMEs (Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises) etc. If necessary, bringing contractual relations to an end with relevant business partners, or to turn to partners with whom the company has indirect relationships. That is a prevention part. As for putting-an-end and/or minimizing the extent of those impacts, the specific actions would include the neutralization of arisen effects t or minimize its extent, including by the payment of damages to the affected persons and of financial compensation to the affected communities, in proportion to the significance and scale of the adverse impact. Other methods are the development of a corrective action plan, again seeking contractual assurances from business partners, making necessary investments and the like (Articles 7 and 8);

• Establishing and maintaining of complaints procedure – the said procedure should enable the affected persons and organizations, or the ones reasonably believing to be affected, to submit complaints in relation to real or potential adverse impacts (Article 9);

• Monitoring – companies should carry out periodic assessments of their own operations and measures, those of their subsidiaries and, where related to the value chains of the company, those of their established business relationships, to monitor the effectiveness of the identification, prevention, mitigation, bringing to an end and minimization of the extent of human rights and environmental adverse impacts. The monitoring should be conducted at least every 12 months or after a significant change occurs (Article 10);

• Public communication on due diligence – companies in scope of Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) must communicate relevant due diligence information via their annual reports in accordance with CSRD requirements. Companies not subject to CSRD must publish annual statement on their websites, on language in a language customary in the sphere of international business. The statement shall be published by 30 April each year, covering the previous calendar year (Article 11).

Climate transition plan – not a necessary step per se, but a specific obligation to ensure that a company’s business model complies with limiting global warming to 1.5°C. This obligation will add to the disclosures under the CSRD, which does not by itself require companies to have climate change transition plans. For companies in scope of both the CSDDD requirement and the CSRD reporting requirements, this likely means that they will have to report on their transition plan as part of their annual CSRD disclosure.

Non-compliance with CSDDD requirements may result in a pecuniary fine by national supervising bodies which are to be established by Member States (administrative liability, amounting up to 5% of the company’s total net turnover), i.e. damages compensation to affected persons and/or organizations (civil liability – the procedure could be instilled within five years from the damage occurrence).

 

Hitting the Brick Wall

The CSDDD, however, was not adopted. Namely, the Directive did not receive a “green light” in the European Council – there was no (qualified) majority to approve the final text of the Directive. This was mainly due to Germany’s decision to abstain from voting, which other countries quickly followed thus eroding the support swiftly. As a result, the CSDDD is off the table (for now) and the EU institutions have to go back to the drawing board.

The reasons for such an unprecedented outcome were mainly political. Apart from Germany’s actions, France went in with a suggestion to water down its effects, followed by Italy soon after. The criticisms revolved mainly around stiffing the businesses with bureaucracy, as well as indirectly affecting smaller and medium-sized businesses due to focus on supply chains, overreaching its extraterritoriality to the unreasonable extent.

With its life “hanging at the balance”, necessary amendments and compromises had to be reached.

 

Amendments That Led to Council Acceptance

The Directive has recently been accepted on the Council level and it now remains to be seen whether EU Parliament will endorse it. The key to its acceptance was in making adjustments, which vary significantly from the original text.

Some of these amendments include:

• Lifting the threshold – the threshold for application of the Directive is now changed to companies with 1000+ employees and EUR 450 mil. net annual turnover. Similarly, the threshold for non-EU companies was increased to EUR 450 mil. in the EU;
• Deletion of high-risk sectors – as opposed to the original text the high-risk industries provision is now deleted, but leaving the space for later implementation, if necessary;
• Chain of activities – the downstream part of the definition has been limited by deleting the references to the disposal of the product, and by limiting it to business partners who carry out activities in the name and on behalf of the company. Therefore, the indirect business relationships are now deleted;
• Civil liability – the Member States are now given greater flexibility, by having them provide for “reasonable conditions” under which injured parties may authorize the organizations to bring actions to enforce their rights.
These are only some of the amendments introduced (we did not touch the transition periods, climate transition plans and the like).

 

What Does the Future Hold?

In light of the recent events, the future of the CSDDD is not yet certain. Namely, the EU parliament must now accept the current text in its finally plenary sitting in April, before the upcoming elections in June. After that, the Council must formally adopt it in order for it to be finally considered as “done deal”.

However, once in force, the ramifications would be massive because the businesses would need to make a U-turn in their policies, adapting to new circumstances in order to maintain their reputation, good brand and customer trust.

 

Authors:

Aleksandar Čermelj, Senior Associate, IVVK in cooperation with LexQuire, aleksandar.cermelj@lexquire-ivvk.rs

Katarina Marković, Junior Associate, IVVK in cooperation with LexQuire, katarina.markovic@ivvk.rs

 

*The information in this document does not represent legal advice and is provided for general informational purposes only.

**Partner, Senior Associate, Associate and/or Junior Associate refers to Independent Attorney at Law in cooperation with IVVK Lawyers in Cooperation with LexQuire.

22/03/2024

SHARE the NEWS on :

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ACQUIRING THE ENERGY PERMIT

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

EU’S New AML Measures

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive: Navigating Trough the Turmoil

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Jurisdiction for Issuing Construction Permits

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

EU Minimum Corporate Income Tax Directive: What to Know and What to Expect?

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Marking Data Protection Day: A Reminder of How Important it Is to Protect Privacy

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Drag Along and Tag Along in Domestic Legal System

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

AI Act - Challenges of Artificial Intelligence To the Global Market

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Understanding NPLs: Scheme, Serbian Context & Notes of Economists

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Insurance – Luxury or Necessity?

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Claims Secured by a Mortgage and the Statute of Limitations

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Alert: New Regulation Concerning Incentives in the Hotel Industry

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Most Profitable Investments In The Republic Of Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Annex to the Employment Contract for Transfer to Another Suitable Job (Due to the Needs of the Work Process and Organization)

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Delayed justice is denied justice

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Regulation of the Government of the Republic of Serbia on electricity delivery and supply conditions: Outlining the conditions for connection to the grid

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Shareholders agreement – General overview and important clauses

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia drafting new Law on Information Security

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

IVVK Lawyers becomes part of the LexQuire family

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia looking for strategic partners for solar power plants

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Benefits of employee stock ownership plan in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

In 5 years 450 new RES power plants in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Co-ownership of share in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia hosts Specialised Expo 2027

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Uncovering legal challenges of AI

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Energy related Memorandum of Understanding signed with UK

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia established quota for solar power auctions

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE The dark side of ESG

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE ESG principles and their impact on corporate world

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia focuses on energy, IT and biotech

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbian Orthodox Church becomes solar prosumer

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Notary Chamber of Serbia releases E-Notary app

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE CFD brokers hiding behind Terms and Conditions

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Process of company founding in Serbia goes electronic

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Upward trend of renewables confirmed in 2022

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Obtaining hemp cultivation permit in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Legal aspects of cultivation, trade and use of cannabis in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia's 2023 economic growth depends on IT sector

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Legal considerations of seasonal work engagements in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

IVVK Lawyers hosted lecture for foreign business people

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ICT sector recorded 2 billion EUR surplus

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Growth of creative industries sector in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia large biomass energy potential

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Rich gold deposit found in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia among top 3 global raspberry producers

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbian Chamber of Commerce present in Dubai

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Establishment of Serbia-Qatar Business Council

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia's Securities Commission approved establishment of a new AIF

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia adopted Air Quality Protection Program 2022-2030

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Danube region transnational cooperation program 2021-2027 approved

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Rakija entered UNESCO-s Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity List

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Possible electricity import from Azerbaijan

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia's unique solar energy storage solution

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia abundant in rare minerals

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Luxury Real Estate Market in Montenegro

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

LexQuire meets IVVK Lawyers

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Law on Agency Employment aimed at prevention of labor abuse

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

11 cities and municipalities signed a Memorandum of Understanding

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Price increase of housing units in Montenegro by 40%

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Foreign trade in goods increased by 35.1%

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Tax Incentives to Employers Who Hire Newly Registered Residents of Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Apartments as the leading segment of the real estate market

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Businessmen optimistic about the third quarter of 2022

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Inflation in Serbia amounted to 12.8% in July

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Bank fees and commissions to remain stable in 2023

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Law on Alternative Investment Funds

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Montenegro introduces auctions for renewable energy sources

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Legal framework for investments in energy facilities in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Hydro Power Plants as a possible energy solution for Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Four-day working week in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Crops estimations for 2022 in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

ARTICLE Innovation clusters as high-potential solution for SMEs

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Customs-free importing quotas for Eurasian Economic Community 2023

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

IVVK JOB OPENING We are hiring Junior Associates

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Startups Attract More Than USD 135 Million to Serbia in 2021

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Construction Plan for a Wind Farm in Bor

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

IVVK Lawyers participated in Confindustria HR Forum

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

IVVK-UpSkill Workshop "Presentation on social and TV media"

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia and Azerbaijan up for cooperation in the energy field

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Energy permits digitized starting November

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Belgrade declared city with greatest economic potential in region

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Digitalization of fiscalization and invoicing in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

New Register of Investment Locations in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Paysend opens new European tech center in Serbia

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia allows free export of flour from 15 May

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Serbia to announce auctions for renewable energy power plants

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Energy most important for economic development

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Action Plan for Implementation of Digitalisation Programme in Health System

PREVIOUS

PREVIOUS

Oracle Corporation opens regional centre in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

ACQUIRING THE ENERGY PERMIT

NEXT

NEXT

EU’S New AML Measures

NEXT

NEXT

Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive: Navigating Trough the Turmoil

NEXT

NEXT

Jurisdiction for Issuing Construction Permits

NEXT

NEXT

EU Minimum Corporate Income Tax Directive: What to Know and What to Expect?

NEXT

NEXT

Marking Data Protection Day: A Reminder of How Important it Is to Protect Privacy

NEXT

NEXT

Drag Along and Tag Along in Domestic Legal System

NEXT

NEXT

AI Act - Challenges of Artificial Intelligence To the Global Market

NEXT

NEXT

Understanding NPLs: Scheme, Serbian Context & Notes of Economists

NEXT

NEXT

Insurance – Luxury or Necessity?

NEXT

NEXT

Claims Secured by a Mortgage and the Statute of Limitations

NEXT

NEXT

Alert: New Regulation Concerning Incentives in the Hotel Industry

NEXT

NEXT

Most Profitable Investments In The Republic Of Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

Annex to the Employment Contract for Transfer to Another Suitable Job (Due to the Needs of the Work Process and Organization)

NEXT

NEXT

Delayed justice is denied justice

NEXT

NEXT

Regulation of the Government of the Republic of Serbia on electricity delivery and supply conditions: Outlining the conditions for connection to the grid

NEXT

NEXT

Shareholders agreement – General overview and important clauses

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia drafting new Law on Information Security

NEXT

NEXT

IVVK Lawyers becomes part of the LexQuire family

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia looking for strategic partners for solar power plants

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Benefits of employee stock ownership plan in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

In 5 years 450 new RES power plants in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Co-ownership of share in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia hosts Specialised Expo 2027

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Uncovering legal challenges of AI

NEXT

NEXT

Energy related Memorandum of Understanding signed with UK

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia established quota for solar power auctions

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE The dark side of ESG

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE ESG principles and their impact on corporate world

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia focuses on energy, IT and biotech

NEXT

NEXT

Serbian Orthodox Church becomes solar prosumer

NEXT

NEXT

Notary Chamber of Serbia releases E-Notary app

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE CFD brokers hiding behind Terms and Conditions

NEXT

NEXT

Process of company founding in Serbia goes electronic

NEXT

NEXT

Upward trend of renewables confirmed in 2022

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Obtaining hemp cultivation permit in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Legal aspects of cultivation, trade and use of cannabis in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia's 2023 economic growth depends on IT sector

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Legal considerations of seasonal work engagements in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

IVVK Lawyers hosted lecture for foreign business people

NEXT

NEXT

ICT sector recorded 2 billion EUR surplus

NEXT

NEXT

Growth of creative industries sector in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia large biomass energy potential

NEXT

NEXT

Rich gold deposit found in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia among top 3 global raspberry producers

NEXT

NEXT

Serbian Chamber of Commerce present in Dubai

NEXT

NEXT

Establishment of Serbia-Qatar Business Council

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia's Securities Commission approved establishment of a new AIF

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia adopted Air Quality Protection Program 2022-2030

NEXT

NEXT

Danube region transnational cooperation program 2021-2027 approved

NEXT

NEXT

Rakija entered UNESCO-s Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity List

NEXT

NEXT

Possible electricity import from Azerbaijan

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia's unique solar energy storage solution

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia abundant in rare minerals

NEXT

NEXT

Luxury Real Estate Market in Montenegro

NEXT

NEXT

LexQuire meets IVVK Lawyers

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Law on Agency Employment aimed at prevention of labor abuse

NEXT

NEXT

11 cities and municipalities signed a Memorandum of Understanding

NEXT

NEXT

Price increase of housing units in Montenegro by 40%

NEXT

NEXT

Foreign trade in goods increased by 35.1%

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Tax Incentives to Employers Who Hire Newly Registered Residents of Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

Apartments as the leading segment of the real estate market

NEXT

NEXT

Businessmen optimistic about the third quarter of 2022

NEXT

NEXT

Inflation in Serbia amounted to 12.8% in July

NEXT

NEXT

Bank fees and commissions to remain stable in 2023

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Law on Alternative Investment Funds

NEXT

NEXT

Montenegro introduces auctions for renewable energy sources

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Legal framework for investments in energy facilities in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

Hydro Power Plants as a possible energy solution for Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Four-day working week in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

Crops estimations for 2022 in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

ARTICLE Innovation clusters as high-potential solution for SMEs

NEXT

NEXT

Customs-free importing quotas for Eurasian Economic Community 2023

NEXT

NEXT

IVVK JOB OPENING We are hiring Junior Associates

NEXT

NEXT

Startups Attract More Than USD 135 Million to Serbia in 2021

NEXT

NEXT

Construction Plan for a Wind Farm in Bor

NEXT

NEXT

IVVK Lawyers participated in Confindustria HR Forum

NEXT

NEXT

IVVK-UpSkill Workshop "Presentation on social and TV media"

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia and Azerbaijan up for cooperation in the energy field

NEXT

NEXT

Energy permits digitized starting November

NEXT

NEXT

Belgrade declared city with greatest economic potential in region

NEXT

NEXT

Digitalization of fiscalization and invoicing in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

New Register of Investment Locations in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

Paysend opens new European tech center in Serbia

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia allows free export of flour from 15 May

NEXT

NEXT

Serbia to announce auctions for renewable energy power plants

NEXT

NEXT

Energy most important for economic development

NEXT

NEXT

Action Plan for Implementation of Digitalisation Programme in Health System

NEXT

NEXT

Oracle Corporation opens regional centre in Serbia